TomboyX Report Part 1: Marketing to a Niche Audience

The Industry

Shifting culture and shifting markets always go hand in hand, providing the opportunity for old brands and companies to fall behind, and new ones to rise up and take their places. We see this especially with clothing companies, as can be tracked through the rise and fall of Forever 21.

TomboyX is one of the companies, among many, seeking to make a name for itself within the underwear and swimwear industries in the United States. Their products appeal to the trends of nontraditional gender expression becoming more and more popular, and the push to include plus-size models; a trend which both Calvin Klein and Victoria's Secret have participated in.

So let's take a look at the industry. The global lingerie market was found to be worth around $93 billion in 2017, and is projected to grow to $125 billion by 2024. Note the words "global" and "lingerie". Of course an industry selling underwear would make billions, considering that there are billions of people on the planet and probably most of them buy underwear, but lingerie is defined as by Dictionary.com as "women's intimate apparel".


According to Statistica, revenue for underwear in the United States amounts to $286,787 million in 2019. 98,683 million, or 34.4% of that amount is attributed to women, while only 11.8% is attributed to men, and the remainder is T-shirts and Singlets which are not categorized as gender-specific. 



When thinking about how gender is constructed in society (at least in the United States), clothing is one of the biggest ways people delineate men and women. Baby boys wear blue, and baby girls wear pink. Men wear suits, and women wear dresses. Underwear is no exception. Men wear boxers and briefs, women wear bras and panties. Yes, part of this is rooted in many women needing bras for support, but the marketing of these products usually focuses way more on sex appeal than on practicality.
Dividing men and women like this is obviously very stereotypical and not how many people live their lives, as well as problematic for many queer, trans, and non-binary people, but it also hugely impacts how clothing is sold. Even with the rise of more gender neutral clothing and more clothing options for larger people, underwear models are typically presented as very thin, feminine women, and fit, masculine men.

Niche Appeal and Competition

Founded in 2012 by Fran Dunaway and Naomi Gonzalez and based in Seattle, Washington, TomboyX advertises itself as providing what's missing from the more mainstream underwear providers:
"underwear that any body could feel comfortable in, regardless of where they fell on the size or gender spectrum"  
The company has gotten attention from Teen Vogue for being trans-friendly, Nylon for being eco-friendly, Fast Company for being queer-friendly more broadly, Buzzfeed surrounding Pride, and Bustle for embracing different body types, among many other sites. Their rallying calls are statements like "We fit who you are because fitting in has never been the point", and "Be exactly who you were born to be–no apologies".

While multiple articles have been published about LGBTQ+ friendly underwear brands, by sites like Nylon and Them, TomboyX and another company called Pyramid Seven are the only ones that even register in Google Trends, with TomboyX taking the lead in the summer of 2016.



This suggests that while there are multiple companies appealing to this niche market, TomboyX is the most popular, and shows a distinct slope in terms of being more recognized in recent years. The peak so far has been in June of 2019 which matches up with Pride month and the release of a rainbow collection.

This Pride in particular was accompanied by pushback against "rainbow capitalism" and the involvement of corporations in pride exploiting LGBTQ+ people, so there was extra press encouraging people to buy clothing for Pride from queer-owned or queer-friendly companies, making it an especially well-timed year for TomboyX to release this collection.


Another collection that TomboyX released this October is called First Line Underwear, which involves different styles of underwear with built in leak protection for people who have periods or incontinence. If Pyramid Seven is their primary competitor, this could lead to TomboyX being even more successful because the other company specializes exclusively in boxer brief style underwear with period protection, and now TomboyX has a similar product with more options.

Social Media


TomboyX can be found on the expected social media sites: Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and YouTube, and their audience engagement is fairly limited, though they seem to post loosely every day on every platform besides YouTube. TomboyX's Facebook page has 203k followers and 205k likes, with average posts garnering about 200 interactions each. Their most popular post in the last month, with 1.7k interactions linked to an article about Indigenous Peoples' Day, and acknowledged the history of the land they live on. The responses to this post were mixed, and a lot of the engagement involved people arguing in the comments, but it was received well overall. Links make up 65% of the posts on the Facebook page, and get the most engagement.


On Twitter the company has 11k followers, and almost 5k tweets since 2013 when it was created. This includes promotional posts as well as posts linking to articles posted on the site's blog, and posts promoting articles they have been written about in. Of the social media sites this seems to attract the least amount of attention, and the account is not verified, which reinforces that impression.

TomboyX's Instagram presence is stronger, with a verified account listing 162k followers and 2,563 posts so far. This account has gained almost 12k followers in the last month including 721 on September 30th when their Halloween line was announced, and they feature pictures of customers wearing TomboyX products who post the pictures with #tomboyx in the description. The average number of interactions here is 1.9k, higher than any of the other social media platforms they operate on.

In terms of YouTube, views per video might run anywhere between 100 and a few thousand, with the most viewed video so far having been released in 2015, with over 8k views and featuring famous androgynous model Rain Dove wearing TomboyX underwear. YouTube functions differently than other social media sites in terms of what is required to post, and it seems in the best interest of the company to only post here when they have filmed advertisements.


In summation, TomboyX is a company that advertises to a fairly niche audience of people who are displeased with the mainstream offerings of underwear, especially underwear advertised toward women. Their biggest draws are that their products are queer-friendly, eco-friendly, and inclusive of different types of bodies, and the platform they advertise on most successfully is Instagram.

Currently their Halloween line is being advertised the most, and featured on the homepage of their website as well, with the tagline "Underwear for All Souls". This falls in line with their signature offerings of quirky prints, and has gained the Instagram followers, and likely the company sales.

Based on the success of the Rain Dove clip on YouTube above others, TomboyX seems like it could benefit from getting popular queer influencers to promote their products and attract a larger audience of the type of people who would be likely to buy their products.

Social media statistics sourced by Socialbakers.   

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

VSCO Girls: Memes and Marketing

Queerness on Social Media

YouTube Thumbnails and the Art of Attention Grabbing