Discrimination on YouTube and Internal Groundswell Rising Up

What do you do if you put a lot of effort and many hours of work into writing, filming, and editing a video, only to upload it and find out that YouTube has demonetized it, meaning that they will not run any ads on the video, and that you will therefore not make any money from your hard work?

What if you start to realize that this happens whenever you use the word "gay" in your video titles?

This is a problem faced by many LGBTQ YouTubers, and the answer for many is to file a lawsuit against YouTube.


Charlene Li and Josh Bernoff's Groundswell: Winning in a World Transformed by Social Technologies discusses various aspects of the groundswell both operating outside of a company and within it. But what happens to a company like YouTube that has to manage direct employees as well as the over 23 million YouTube channels with uploaded videos, the viewers accessing these videos, and the advertisers paying to run their ads before and during other creators videos?

Most YouTubers are technically independent contractors but even the name of their profession ties them directly to this platform, and YouTube has the power to decide if their content is appropriate for advertisers to associate with as well as whether it should be age restricted or not. This results in a community of people who work for YouTube, have a lot of social power, know how to get in contact with each other, and are willing to fight back if they feel that YouTube has done them wrong and/or will not listen.

The example Li and Bernoff use in Groundswell when discussing groundswell within a company is Best Buy's Blue Shirt Nation. They describe how Best Buy had a website called blueshirtnation.com which functioned as an internal community site for employees to share thoughts about how the company could improve, and just generally socialize:
"Internal groundswell applications like Blue Shirt Nation can make [employees] feel empowered, connected, and more committed on a day-to-day basis." (Li & Bernoff, pg. 236)
At first glance, YouTube seems like it already is such a website, in that many community members socialize with each other and can share thoughts about problems with YouTube itself. Unfortunately those in charge have not demonstrated that they are listening to the groundswell, and the CEO denied claims that LGBTQ+ content is specifically demonetized as discussed in the video below.


Rather than listening to the complaints that certain types of videos are facing discrimination with support and a pledge to solve that problem, YouTube has denied these claims, or blamed them on an algorithm, and is now facing a lawsuit for it.

These critiques of YouTube also claim that content restrictions are applied more loosely to some of the platforms biggest creators, essentially painting the picture that YouTube allows creators that benefit them less to be hurt by algorithms while privileging others. The hashtags #dontbeevil and #LGBTQvsGoogleYouTube are being used on Twitter to draw attention to this issue.   

What do you think YouTube could do in this situation to show the groundswell that it is listening? Do you think it has enough power that accusations like this and a lawsuit will even create a problem? 

Comments

  1. Hi, Savannah! I think this is the only example that's been posed this semester of the groundswell actually taking legal action against a company. YouTube is clearly in the wrong here. The company won’t even admit to or fix its problem. To handle this situation effectively, YouTube should have accepted responsibility for the demonetization of the videos and promised to fix the issues. That way, it would show the groundswell it was listening and trying to resolve the problem. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Savannah,
    Oh no, what a mess YouTube is in! I have heard so many people express dissatisfaction with the way that their videos get demonetized. If YouTube does not respond to the rising dissatisfaction of the groundswell, they're gonna be in trouble YouTube can address that it's fair why people feel discriminated against and that they're taking steps to fix their algorithm. We discussed how Domino's and Chipotle both did that, they accepted blame gracefully, you can say.
    Thanks for sharing, it was an interesting read!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

VSCO Girls: Memes and Marketing

Queerness on Social Media

YouTube Thumbnails and the Art of Attention Grabbing